In need of a new bag

I need a new bag. I would really LOVE JCrew's metallic hobo...but alas my wallet is not that thick these days, and I think the "smaller" one is gone, which is what I want...

I will just live vicariously through A Bigger Closet and Patina...

So, some other bag options, that lay more in my price range...

Cassie Hobo $58

Samantha Satchel $38

Four in One Slouchy Messenger Bag and Shoulder Purse $56

I couldn't find any cute metallic ones that didn't look uber cheap... so I stuck to black. I like all of these. Which do you like?